Where flavors meet
Welcome to Pizza 51
Pizza 51, located at 5060 Oak St in Kansas City, MO, offers an inviting atmosphere and a diverse menu that highlights flavorful pizzas crafted with fresh ingredients. Regular patrons rave about the distinct Highway Special and the exceptional quality of their unique bread. The bustling restaurant creates a lively vibe, perfect for enjoying a meal with friends. While the ordering process requires customers to head to the counter for drinks, the overall experience is well worth it. With fantastic service and delicious options, Pizza 51 is a local gem that's definitely worth revisiting for any pizza lover.
Inspired Moments
Enjoy a mix of flavors and experiences
BYO Slice Cheese
12 Count Wings
Meatball Sub
Italian Beef
Story & Atmosphere
Pizza 51
Welcome to Pizza 51, a culinary gem located at 5060 Oak St, Kansas City, MO 64112. This delightful pizzeria has quickly become a beloved destination for pizza aficionados and casual diners alike. With its bustling atmosphere and communal vibe, Pizza 51 invites you to indulge in flavorful slices crafted from fresh, quality ingredients.
The menu at Pizza 51 boasts a variety of unique offerings, with standout selections like the Highway Special that customers have raved about. Donald Wooten describes it as "really tasty" and filling, illustrating the generous portions and quality that keep patrons coming back. Meanwhile, Mohammad Zare highlights the exceptional bread as "absolutely amazing," complimenting its perfect balance of softness and crunch. This attention to detail in both preparation and presentation does not go unnoticed; guests can expect a pizza that is both visually appealing and satisfying to the palate.
One aspect of Pizza 51 that adds to its charm is the vibrant, friendly atmosphere. According to Mayela Alvarez, the customer service is top-notch, with staff like Joe making a genuine effort to engage with diners about their meals. This personal touch enhances the overall experience, allowing you to feel more connected to the food and ambiance.
Of course, no review would be complete without addressing the practicality of dining here. While the service model may require a quick trip back to the counter for drink refills, many find it a small trade-off for the quality of the food and the inviting outdoor patio area. Customers like Darin Altenburg appreciate the variety, choosing creative combinations like pineapple with Canadian bacon and bacon with a touch of cream cheese—a testament to the innovative spirit of the kitchen.
While some may argue that Pizza 51 may not rival the best New York pizzerias, it certainly stands out among its Kansas counterparts. At Pizza 51, the marriage of delicious flavors, excellent service, and a warm atmosphere makes for an unforgettable dining experience that is well worth your time. So, whether you're a local seeking a favorite spot or a visitor exploring Kansas City, make sure to stop by Pizza 51 for your slice of happiness.
What Guests Say
Guestbook
“ The Pizza was really good. It was really busy with lots of people seeming to enjoy the Pizza. I had a slice of the Highway Special and it was very tasty. It filled me up and it wasn’t very expensive. ”
“ The pizza was delicious — flavorful, perfectly cooked, and super satisfying. What really surprised me, though, was the bread — absolutely amazing, soft but with just the right crunch. Great food, great vibes. Definitely a spot worth revisiting. ”
“ Nothing so special about this place. Pizza in Kansas is lackluster. This place isn’t. The pizza was pretty good. But not amazing. It didn’t blow a New Yorkers socks off. ”
“ My husband and I came here for the first time this past Monday. We both agree that the customer service was exceptional! Joe was very nice and asked how our meal was. You do have to order your food before sitting down, which is no big deal. The restaurant itself was very inviting. We ordered the special, a slice of pizza and salad. We had the highway slice, and I'd have to say it was delicious! As for the paper plates and plastic silverware, I don't know what the big issue people have about this. Those things don't bother me one bit. I truly enjoyed this place and will be there again, this time wirh my kids! ”
“ I did two different slices.Slice #1...pineapple, Canadian bacon, cream cheese, bacon and onion slice was my favorite. Slice #2...The cow town minus the black olives and mushrooms was good too. Self serve drinks with free refills. Outdoor patio area was nice today with the games showing. Service was great and food arrived hot and fresh. ”